Sun - Thurs
11am - 10pm
Fri & Sat
11am - 11pm

Come on in for the Best Pizza in St. Pete since 1972.

Pizza • Cold & Hot Subs • Salads • Beer

Pizza & Friends. What more can you ask for?

Located in Pinellas County, Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza brings that New York flavor to St. Pete with style. With fun & modern decorations, this is a must-try for all pizza lovers.

See our menu
"It's not just pizza, it's an experience!"
- Toby, New York
✔ Arcade
✔ tunes
✔ beer
✔ memories.

Tons of pizza & tons of fun.

We are serving one of the best New York style Pizza and Subs since 1972. We offer dine-in or take out service, we promise it’s worth the trip.

We are open 7 days a week. Come and visit us now! For 49 years we have been serving the New York Style Pizza and Subs in St. Petersburg!

See our menu
Pizza • Cold & Hot Subs • Salads • Beer • Pizza • Cold & Hot

Alright... let's get some pizza! (& garlic knots)

check out the menucall to order
Fan-favorite
Garlic Knots!
CALL NOW TO PLACE YOUR ORDER

Where To Find Us:

3523 49th Street N, St. Petersburg, FL 33710
Sun-Thurs: 11am-10pm
Fri & Sat: 11am-11pm
727-522-2717